v4vhse
Welcome to your own forum
v4vhse

A forum for all VHSE staff in Kerala service and for students.Also this site is dedicated to all educational aspirants

For publishing announcements or any other matters send the same to v4vhse@gmail.com

Log in

I forgot my password



Search
 
 

Display results as :
 


Rechercher Advanced Search

Poll

Do you favor/oppose General Transfer

56% 56% [ 199 ]
2% 2% [ 6 ]
33% 33% [ 119 ]
3% 3% [ 9 ]
7% 7% [ 24 ]

Total Votes : 357

Top posters
Malamaram chakkappan (567)
 
raman (428)
 
pareekutty (267)
 
safeerm (97)
 
vivaradoshi (78)
 
satheesh (78)
 
icsure (74)
 
dilna (68)
 
ganeshh (65)
 
Nissangan (61)
 

Like/Tweet/+1
Statistics
We have 1336 registered users
The newest registered user is tarlyjames

Our users have posted a total of 2314 messages in 1231 subjects
Affiliates
free forum

Navigation
 Portal
 Index
 Memberlist
 Profile
 FAQ
 Search

You are not connected. Please login or register

v4vhse » Career Corner » Current Affairs » UGC NET DECEMBER 2012 - The two methods of top 15% calculation

UGC NET DECEMBER 2012 - The two methods of top 15% calculation

View previous topic View next topic Go down  Message [Page 1 of 1]

vivaradoshi


SILVER
SILVER
UGC has announced that the candidates for December 2012 for Lectureship (NET) and JRF should be selected in a step by step process. A selection list of candidates who acquired minimum is prepared in both subject wise and category wise. For example for Economics 4 list is prepared.
Economics General, Economics OBC NCL,Economics SC/ST, Economics PWD. For other subjects the 4 lists are prepared. It is not clear the list will be pure or composite. That means sometimes the first list will be common comprising all candidates, for second list only general is excluded and
contain both OBC NCL,SC/ST and PWD and the third and fourth contain the concerned category only.
Thanks to the model provided here by Malamaram Chakkappan, I like to analyse further by taking the above concept
Subject- Economics
Total Candidates-Suppose 1000
General (40 40 50) total applied- 400
OBC NCL (35 35 45) total applied-300
SC/ST (35 35 40) total applied- 200
PWD(35 35 40) Total applied- 100

% of those who acquire minimum (assume) Gen 40%, OBC 45% and SC/ST/PWD 50%

So the no.of candidates acquiring minimum will be as follows

GENERAL (400X 40%= 160) and will comprise in the following class
Aggregate% No.of Candidates
Above 80% -------------------- 5
70- 80 ------------------------- 10
60-70--------------------------- 30
50-60 -------------------------- 50
44.57%-50---------------------- 65
Total ---------------------------160

OBC NCL (300X45%= 135) and will comprise in the following class

Aggregate% No.of Candidates
Above 80% -------------------- 3
70- 80 ------------------------- 8
60-70-------------------------- 19
50-60-------------------------- 40
44.57-50----------------------- 45
40-44.57%--------------------- 20
Total -------------------------- 135

SC/ST (200X50%=100) and will comprise in the following class

Aggregate% No.of Candidates
Above 80%---------------------- 2
70- 80 -------------------------- 5
60-70 --------------------------- 7
50-60 --------------------------26
44.57-50 ----------------------20
40-44.57% ------------------- 20
37.71-40----------------------- 20
Total---------------------------- 100
PWD (100X50%=50) and will comprise in the following class

Aggregate% No.of Candidates
Above 80% --------------------- 0
70- 80 --------------------------3
60-70 ---------------------------4
50-60--------------------------- 8
44.57-50------------------------ 8
40-44.57%---------------------- 7
37.71-40----------------------- 20
Total -------------------------- 50





In the first method when individual category wise are prepared for each subject the result will be as above. So 160 nos from General,135 from Obc, 100 from SC/ST and 50 from PWD can be cleared (Note that it is
based on assumption on the no.of candidates applied and actual situation the no.of SC/ST may not be 20%-For easy calculation here 20% is assumed as SC/ST)
And the top15% will be as follows

General- 160X 15%= 24
OBC - 135X 15% = 20
SC/ST- 100X15%= 15
PWD- 50X 15% = 8
total 445 ---------67

So out of 1000, 445 (44.5%) will be acquire minimum and 67 (6.7%) will clear NET

Now we can analyse the Second Method




The first list will be containing all those who acquire minimum 40 40 50 including all categories. Here top OBC,PWD and SC/ST are considered as General candidates and the General candidates also may be benefited for 15% is taken from whole. Thus the first combined list will be as follows
Aggregate% No.of Candidates
Above 80%----------------- 10
70- 80--------------------- 26
60-70 --------------------- 60
50-60--------------------- 124
44.57%-50 --------------- 138
Total --------------------- 358

So For categoryI (Gene+ obc+ sc/st+pwd) there will be 358 candidates and 15% is 53

Calculation of composition of this 53
1] All from above 80% class --------10
2] All from 70-80 class--------------26
total-------------------------------36
Remaining -----53-36=17
17 Candidates from the 60-70 class will be selected as follows

Class 60-70----- General------ obc ------ sc/st------- pwd--- total

-----------------30 -----------19 -------- 7 ---------- 4------ 60
selected--------- 8(50%)------ 6 -------- 2 ---------- 1 -------17
Remaining ------- 22-----------13 --------5 -----------3 ------43

The 22 nos remaining in general category has no chance in further selection process. They are out. The following table will show the position of category in this preparation

Class ----------- General------ obc-------- sc/st ------pwd -------- total
Above 80% --------5 -----------3 ----------2 --------- 0 -----------10
70- 80 ----------- 10---------- 8 ---------- 5 ----------3 ---------- 26
60-70 ------------ 8 -----------6---------- 2----------- 1---------- 17
Total------------- 23-----------17--------- 9 ---------- 4---------- 53

So General candidates have not any significant difference in result of both type. In first method 24 candidates from general and in second method it is 23

The second list contains OBC NCL,SC/St and PWD remaining Candidates. It is as follows
Class ---------- OBC -------SC/St ------ PWD --------Total
60-70(remaining)-13 --------- 5 ---------- 3 ---------- 21
50-60 -----------40 -------- 26---------- 8 ----------74
44.57-50 ------- 45 -------- 20---------- 8 -----------73
40-44.57 --------20--------- 20--------- 7 ------------47
Total----------- 118 ------- 71 -------- 26 -----------215

So 215X 15% = 32 and all the candidates in 60-70 class will be selected. The remaining 11 (32-21) will be selected from 50-60 class as follows

Class 50-60 ----------- OBC ------- SC/St ------PWD -------total
-------------------------40 -----------26 -------8 ----------74
Selected ----------------6 ------------ 3 --------2 ----------11
Remaining ---------------34----------- 23------- 6 -----------63

The remaining OBC (34 nos) has no chance in further selection process. They are out. The overall position of category after this list is as follows

Class ---------- Gen------ obc ------sc/st --------- pwd --------total

From firstlist ---- 23 ------ 17 ------- 9------------- 4 ------------53
60-70 ---- ----------------13 --------5 --------------3----------- 21
50-60 ------ ------------- 6 -------- 3 --------------2 -----------11

Total after II list--23 ----36 --------- 17----------- 9 ----------- 85

For sc/st and pwd minimum is same and therefore need not a combined or inter collaborated list. It is prepared separately from the remaining candidates of that category. So III rd list will be for sc/st only

Class -----------------SC/ST Candicates
50-60 remaining --------- 23
44.57-50---------------- 20
40-44.57---------------- 20
37.71-40 ----------------20
Total --------------------83
So 83X15%=12 candidates are again qualify from this category

And List IV will be for PWD only.It is calculated as follows

Class -------------------PWD Candidates

50-60 remaining -------------6
44.57-50 ------------------- 8
40-44.57-------------------- 7
37.71-40------------------- 20
Total ---------------------- 41

So another 6 more candidates will be selected (41X15%)
The whole analysis of II method can be made as follows

--------------------------Gen ----obc ----sc/st -----Pwd ---Total
No.of Candidates applied - 400 ----300 -----200 ------ 100---- 1000
No.of having minimum -----160 ----135----- 100 ------- 50 -----445
Clear in list I --------------23 -----17 ------ 9 -------- 4 -------53
Remaining after list I ------137---- 118 -----91 --------46----- 392
Clear in List II -------------------- 19 ------ 8 -------- 5------ 32
Remaining after II ---------137---- 99------ 83 ------- 41----- 360
Total Selected after List I- 23 ---- 36------ 17 -------- 9------ 85
Clear in list III ---- ----- ------------------12 ---- ------------12
Remaining After III -------137 ---- 99----- 71--------- 41----- 348
Total selected After I------23 ---- 36----- 29--------- 9------- 97
Clear in List IV ---- ----------------------------------- 6------- 6
Remaining After--------137 ------ 99 ----- 71 -------- 35 -----342
Total Cleared NE--------23 -------36----- 29 ---------15 ----- 103

A comparison of Method I and Method II

------------------------Gen -----obc ----sc/st -------pwd -----total

Cleared in Method I ---- 24 -------20---- 15------- 8------ 67
Cleared in Method II ----23 -------36----- 29 -----15 ----103
Difference ------------ (-1)------ +16--- +14---- +7 -----+36
% of pass in Method I ---15 -------15---- 15----- 15 ----- 15
% of pass in Method II- 14.38---- 26.67 ---29 ---- 30

Though there is no significant difference in in two methods for general, the reservation categories are much benefited. Yet the UGC for lectureship may accept the first method and for JRF the second method is followed.


-----------------------------

----------------------------

----------------------------

v4vhse.forumotion.in

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
ഇത് വിവരവും വിദ്യാഭ്യാസവും ഉള്ളവരുടെ ലോകം.പക്ഷെ ലോകത്ത്‌ കാണുന്നതോ വിവരക്കേടിന്റെ സാമ്രാജ്യങ്ങള്‍........ അവിടെ എന്തും വിളിച്ചുപറയാന്‍ കഴിയുന്ന ഒരാളെ ഉള്ളൂ..... വിവരദോഷി


[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]

View previous topic View next topic Back to top  Message [Page 1 of 1]

Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum